The practical answer
Compare the asking price with prices for similar homes. Keep verified sales separate from adverts. Note the date, how the floor area was measured, the payment terms and what the price includes. If you cannot verify what a buyer paid, say so. This comparison can guide your offer. Only a suitably qualified professional can provide a formal valuation.
Identify the status of every price
An advert tells you what the seller is asking. A reservation is a step towards a sale, and it may have conditions. Ask whether each price is an asking price, a reservation price or the price of a completed sale. Note when it was recorded and how you checked it. One home advertised on several sites is still one home.
Begin with current discovery pages such as Veranda and Cala Sahl Hasheesh, then request a dated proposal for the specific available home. Treat that proposal as asking-price information until a different status is substantiated. Avoid describing a withdrawn advert as a confirmed sale or assuming that a crossed-out price was ever achieved.
Use a simple evidence label
Give each entry one of three labels: verified transaction, documented asking offer or unverified indication. These labels are for your own notes. They are not official valuation grades. Note how closely each home matches yours. Even a verified sale is a poor guide if the homes are very different.
RICS' consumer explanation of comparable evidence highlights the importance of recent, verifiable and similar evidence. Ask whether transaction details can be substantiated without exposing another buyer's personal data. If the answer is no, retain the information as an indication with a clear limitation. A confident verbal statement should not silently acquire the weight of documentary evidence.
Compare the home you would actually receive
Start with the same project or a similar setting if you can. Compare the stage of completion, floor, view, layout, condition and spaces included. Two homes with the same bedroom count and advertised area may feel different. Think about shade on the terrace, privacy from neighbours and how easily you can reach shared facilities.
Ask how each floor area was measured before you compare prices per square metre. List terraces and gardens separately so you can see what the total includes. Note any differences in the contract or in how you may use the home. Ask your advisers to review them. Only put a price on a difference if you have evidence for it.
Put prices on the same payment basis
A cash offer and an instalment plan can show the same total but require different payments. List what you would pay now and later. Note which charges the price excludes and what comes with the home. Keep the dated figures in the original currency. If you compare prices in EUR, use the same conversion basis and state it.
Suppose you have a record of a completed sale and a current advert for a similar home. Only the sale shows what a buyer paid. Compare the dates, payment schedules and what each price includes. If you cannot justify an adjustment, mark it as unknown. Do not assume a standard discount.
Keep weak evidence from becoming false precision
If you cannot find relevant completed sales, say so. Check whether the adverts are current, repeated or for homes that differ in important ways. The adverts can show what else is on offer, subject to confirmation. Their average alone cannot tell you what homes sold for or establish market value.
The RICS comparable-evidence professional standard addresses evidence sources and their relative importance. If the decision warrants a formal valuation, ask a suitably qualified valuer with relevant local competence about scope, inspection, assumptions and limitations. A report should be useful because of its evidence and analysis, not simply because it supplies a precise number.
Turn the comparison into a reasoned offer
Write down which home you prefer, your strongest comparisons and what you still need to know. Note which differences you accept. Keep your preferences separate from facts. You may pay more for a layout that suits long stays. That does not prove the home will sell for more later or earn a particular rent.
Use the project collection to keep realistic alternatives in view. Then request a comparison discussion with Hurghadians Property, sharing your shortlisted homes and the basis on which you want them compared. Ask for a current written proposal and supporting explanations. That creates a more productive negotiation than requesting a discount with no reference to the property or terms.
Your buyer checklist
- Label each number as a completed transaction, asking offer or unverified indication.
- Record the evidence date and remove duplicate listings from the sample.
- Compare relevant condition, outlook, layout and completion differences.
- Confirm area definitions before using a price-per-sqm comparison.
- Align payment timing, currency basis, inclusions and additional charges.
- State missing evidence and commission a suitable valuation when needed.
Bring your priorities to the next viewing
Use the same questions for every shortlisted property. Ask for the current information that applies to your chosen home, then bring the answers together before deciding.
